Karlproductions's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Roof]

thats a worthy tribute to the best movie ever made!
i love it!

[RUSH.]

great!

this is a great animation! the plot is very cute and ironic and i could really fast identify with the protagonist.
i don't understand why people want to know where the boy is going and what he wants to accomplish. it's not necessary for the story and an artist must not tell everything and can leave things to your imagination!
you made this in cinema scope? i'd like to see that! especially the scene in the middle of the road! i was so scared for the little guy. a big screen like cinema scope could really intensify the impressions!

gzilbalodis responds:

I love cinemascope and will make all of my shorts in that format. Maybe you should give it a watch on youtube, I think it looks much better in HD and on full screen.

[Dragonfly.]

sad story ...

but a good video anyway!
i don't like the music. but the good thing is, that your animation works really well without it. maybe even better!
ooh .. and the shoes ... the little shoes of the elephant were funny and cute!

Foxcato responds:

Thank you.
Ha ha, I'm glad you think his boots were cute. I really like giving my characters small feet.

[Something On My Face]

cool!

that was very cool! i would like to see this on a big movie screen. maybe that could intense the impressions. and i would like to know how you made this ... but it's okay if you don't want to tell.
maybe some people will complain about the fact that the movie wasn't synchron with the music. but in my opinion this is a very good decision. so you can watch the movie without the music and it still works. otherwise it would be just a clip and couldn't speak for itself.
at some parts your movie is very linear if you know what i mean. thats a good thing because it never gets boring for the viewer. but on the other hand it's just like a normal movie or classic theater play. but there is the potential to break these old simple rules and make something different.
i hope you make some more associative art because i would like to see it.

[48hr Film-fest entry]

WOW!

this is amazing ... and funny ... and amazing!
and you made this in just 2 days? thats really impressive.
and i cannot even think about how to improve or criticize your work!

[Harvesting]

creepy!

that was very good. reminded me of kafka ... or roald dahl! i liked that it was relatively slow. it made the end even more dramatic.
and very good choice with rachmaninov for your music!

[Thomas the elf]

wonderful!

just wonderful!
i loved the expressions on every face of every character! beautiful stereotypes!
and the story and the little details and the music and the drawings and ... it was sooo wonderful!
now i'm in the mood for christmas!

peixeaquatico responds:

thanks

[It's about time...]

lazy people

the audience is getting lazy ... there is so much room for interpretation but you people don't want to think about what you saw and what happened with yourself! the artist was nice enough to write down the meaning of his conceptual work but you still don't want to think about it. all that you want is cheap entertainment!

ps: i really like it! one thing i want to criticize are the ghosts. "The ghosts represent all of our...well, ghosts." this is a bit to ... kitschy and simple for me! but maybe that's just your style. and i hate to say this but it could have been longer to intensify my impressions. nonetheless it is a good animation!

[Shoe- "Egg"]

useless review!

that's so great!
i ... i want to write a review but it's impossible. i'm still paralyzed!
thanks!

SpamClamberton responds:

"I'm still paralyzed! Thanks!"
You won't be thanking me if it's permanent.

[Missing Heart Short Story]

that's wonderful!

you just made my day! although it's a bit kitschy, i think it is wonderful heart warming! and the girl really looked like a good friend of mine. so the plot is even more beautiful for me! ^^

Syringes responds:

Im glad I made your day and thanks for the 10!! : D

Hah I hope your friend keeps her heart though aye?